Home » Dessert News » Reese’s Pie Is Sold Out Online (But Hershey Says Select Club Stores Have It In Limited Quantities)

Reese’s Pie Is Sold Out Online (But Hershey Says Select Club Stores Have It In Limited Quantities)

A Reese's Pie, a giant milk chocolate peanut butter cup on a black plate, with one slice being lifted out, next to its orange Reese's Pie box and plates of slices on a Thanksgiving table.

Reese’s Pie is sold out online. The 9-inch, over-3-pound peanut butter cup went on sale at Hershey’s online store on Monday, November 16, at 9 a.m. ET, for $49.99 with a limit of two per order. By Monday night, the same page read “The REESE’S Pie has sold out.” Hershey hasn’t announced a restock.

That leaves one place to look before Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26: warehouse clubs. In its November 12 announcement, The Hershey Company said the pie is also available in limited quantities at select club locations, and that availability varies by location.

A Reese's Pie, a giant milk chocolate peanut butter cup on a black plate, with one slice being lifted out, next to its orange Reese's Pie box and plates of slices on a Thanksgiving table.
The Reese’s Pie, 9 inches across and over 3 pounds. Photo: The Hershey Company, via PR Newswire.

Where to look now

  • Club stores: Hershey hasn’t said which chains or which warehouses carry the pie, so a call to your nearest club before you drive over can save a trip.
  • Hershey’s store: the pie’s page now offers an email sign-up to hear about future launches. Signing up opts you in to marketing messages from Hershey and its partners, and the page doesn’t say when the pie will be back.

What the Reese’s Pie is

It isn’t a baked pie. There’s no crust and no pie filling. It’s a giant Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup in the shape of a 9-inch pie, made with the same milk chocolate and peanut butter as the regular cups. Reese’s first sold it as a limited-time offer in 2021, and Hershey says it sold out quickly then, too.

If you do find one, Hershey says to keep it at room temperature in a cool, dry place. It doesn’t need the fridge, and a refrigerated pie should sit out for a bit before you cut it.

The candy behind it goes back nearly a century. H.B. Reese, who once worked on one of the Hershey Chocolate Company’s dairy farms, started making candy in his basement on Areba Avenue in Hershey, Pennsylvania, and began making peanut butter cups as part of a candy assortment around 1928, according to the Hershey Community Archives. Hershey bought his company in 1963.

Bake the peanut butter cup flavor instead

Our Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies put the same pairing on a cookie tray. Halved mini peanut butter cups, Reese’s Pieces and milk chocolate chips go into a peanut butter dough, and a few extra cup halves get pressed on top once the cookies come out of the oven.

For something closer to a single giant treat, our copycat Levain Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie folds Reese’s peanut butter chips into a cocoa dough and shapes it into four oversized cookies. And Five Ingredient Peanut Butter Cookies need only brown sugar, creamy peanut butter, an egg, baking soda and chocolate chips.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *