Home » Cookie Collections » 13 Artisanal Cookie Recipes That Taste Better Than The Bakery

13 Artisanal Cookie Recipes That Taste Better Than The Bakery

Pumpkin Spiced Latte Cookies picked by a hand

A bakery-case cookie is all in the details: flaky salt on a caramel chunk, a jam window in a linzer heart, a swirl of piped dough under powdered sugar. Those are the cookies I’d happily pair with a cup of coffee, and they’re also the ones that add up fast at the counter. These 13 artisan cookie recipes bring that look and flavor home, from brown butter and bourbon to caramelized peaches and espresso buttercream. Some are mix-and-bake simple, and others take a chill or a frosting step, which I’ve noted with each one.

1. Salted Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookies

Salted caramel chocolate chunk cookies with pieces of chocolate and caramel and flaky salt on crinkled parchment

A brown sugar dough gets chopped chocolate and caramel candies cut into quarters, then a pinch of sea salt on top. A broken-up Hershey’s bar works for the chunks, or use any chocolate bar you have. The dough chills for 30 minutes before you scoop it.

Get the recipe: Salted Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookies

2. Strawberry Cake Mix Cookies

Pink strawberry cake mix cookies striped with white icing and red, white and blue sprinkles on a white platter beside heart cookie cutters

Strawberry cake mix, oil and two eggs bake into pink cookies, finished with piped lines of store-bought vanilla icing and a shower of sprinkles. It has one of the shortest ingredient lists here, and the cookies bake for just 8 to 10 minutes.

Get the recipe: Strawberry Cake Mix Cookies

3. Valentine’s Whoopie Pie Cookies

Stacked purple and pink whoopie pie cookies filled with white frosting and rolled in pastel sprinkles, the top one with a bite missing

Vanilla cookies tinted red, pink and purple sandwich a simple buttercream of butter, powdered sugar, vanilla and milk, and the edges roll through sprinkles. The dough is split into three bowls for the colors, and you can pick any shades you like to make them outside of February.

Get the recipe: Valentine’s Whoopie Pie Cookies

4. Copycat Panera Lemon Drop Cookies

Large lemon drop cookies dusted with powdered sugar on a wire rack

Lemon juice and zest brighten a buttery sugar cookie dough studded with white chocolate chips, and a dusting of powdered sugar goes on once they’re cool. The dough needs at least 4 hours in the fridge, preferably overnight, so start these a day ahead. The recipe makes 8 big, Panera-sized cookies.

Get the recipe: Copycat Panera Lemon Drop Cookies

5. No Bake Chocolate Covered Raspberry Hearts

Chocolate-covered raspberry hearts stacked and scattered on white, some topped with heart sprinkles and one bitten to show the filling

A stiff dough of powdered sugar, butter, corn syrup and raspberry extract is rolled out, cut into small hearts and dipped in melted semisweet chocolate. There’s no oven involved, but the hearts chill for 30 minutes before dipping and again until the chocolate sets.

Get the recipe: No Bake Chocolate Covered Raspberry Hearts

6. Apple Crisp Cookies

Glazed apple crisp cookies stacked on a cooling rack with a green apple behind them

Diced green apples are caramelized in butter and sugar, then folded into a brown sugar, cinnamon and oat dough and finished with a drizzle of powdered sugar glaze. The dough chills for at least an hour before baking.

Get the recipe: Apple Crisp Cookies

7. Mint Chocolate Chip Shortbread Cookies

A stack of pale green mint chocolate chip shortbread cookies on a white plate

Whipped butter, powdered sugar, flour and mint extract make a pale green shortbread with mini chocolate chips folded through (mint chips work too). There’s no chilling: the dough is spooned onto the sheet, pressed flat and baked.

Get the recipe: Mint Chocolate Chip Shortbread Cookies

8. Valentine’s Day Linzer Cookies

Heart-shaped linzer cookies with red jam centers, dusted with powdered sugar, on a white board beside a red plaid towel

Cinnamon-spiced butter cookies are cut into hearts, half of them with a small heart window, then sandwiched with cherry, raspberry or blackberry jam under a dusting of powdered sugar. The dough rests in the fridge for 30 minutes before rolling.

Get the recipe: Valentine’s Day Linzer Cookies

9. Coffee Kiss Cookies

Piped coffee kiss cookies dusted with powdered sugar on a blue plate

Instant coffee dissolved in hot water flavors a simple dough of butter, powdered sugar and flour, piped through a large star tip into tall swirls. Let them cool completely before the final dusting of powdered sugar.

Get the recipe: Coffee Kiss Cookies

10. Gluten-Free Bourbon Brown Butter Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookies

Chocolate chip cookies topped with pecans on a wire rack beside a jar of pecans

Browned butter, a splash of bourbon and gluten-free all-purpose flour make the dough, which is loaded with dark chocolate chips and butter-toasted pecans and finished with flaky sea salt. The recipe is made with gluten-free flour, but double-check your other ingredients if you’re baking for someone who avoids gluten.

Get the recipe: Gluten-Free Bourbon Brown Butter Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookies

11. The Best Peach Cobbler Cookies

A hand holding a peach cobbler cookie topped with cream cheese frosting and peach pieces above a cooling rack

Diced peaches are lightly caramelized with butter and brown sugar and folded into a cinnamon dough, then the cooled cookies get a cinnamon cream cheese frosting and a few reserved peaches on top. Fresh peaches are best, and well-drained canned peaches stand in when they’re out of season.

Get the recipe: The Best Peach Cobbler Cookies

12. Pumpkin Spice Latte Cookies

A hand lifting a pumpkin spice latte cookie topped with a swirl of espresso buttercream and cinnamon

Pumpkin puree, pumpkin spice and instant espresso go into the cookie, and an espresso buttercream made with heavy cream is piped on top with a pinch of cinnamon. Wait until the cookies are completely cool before you frost them.

Get the recipe: Pumpkin Spice Latte Cookies

13. Almond Crunch Cookies

Almond crunch cookies coated in sliced almonds on a cooling rack and a white plate

Almond flour and almond extract flavor a buttery dough, and each ball is rolled in sliced almonds before it goes in the oven. Pull them when the edges are golden; the centers firm up as they cool.

Get the recipe: Almond Crunch Cookies

Pick one for a coffee break at home, or bake two or three for a cookie tray that looks like it came out of a bakery box. There are more themed sets in my cookie collections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *